Brent Sherwin
Brent Sherwin
He is the only player along with a couple of the young lads who can come out with his head held high. Thought he did everything he could to get us over the whitewash, with some great passing and kicking like the 40-20 and the bomb that caused confusion between winger and full back in the second half, not to mention that chip over the top- he should have had more support not just from Stuart Donlan. He created enough chances for the team to win the match 10 times over, but no one could give him the support he required.
In defence he really made some key tackles and timely interventions from loose balls as he always seems to do, and gave a real captains knock in my opinion. Showed a real determination which seemed absent in alot of other players in what was a terribly embarrassing performance.
In defence he really made some key tackles and timely interventions from loose balls as he always seems to do, and gave a real captains knock in my opinion. Showed a real determination which seemed absent in alot of other players in what was a terribly embarrassing performance.
- dettoriman
- Super League Player
- Posts: 10692
- Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 15:25
- Twitter: Dettoriman
- Location: Probably Big Fella's
- Contact:
He got some right stick yesterday and much of this was justified but not to the extent of what he recieved, Brent Sherwin didnt lose us the game yesterday - but you would have thought he did from where i was stood
The Drop goal, Should have landed it, if you were asked for positioning from where to take it that would be ideal
The Penalty, Why did he take it when joe was on the field? Why did we opt for the 2 if we knew sherwin would take it?
A few kicks that went dead in goal were very very poor and even the bomb the winger dropped was a bad kick - Far too long but the winger made a howler
I do however think he defended very well - he dashed in from the wing for there first try but it was 3 on 1 so cant fault him, and made some key tackles when needed and the guy is a quality ball handler, He needs a good 6 and a decent pack to work with though
The Drop goal, Should have landed it, if you were asked for positioning from where to take it that would be ideal
The Penalty, Why did he take it when joe was on the field? Why did we opt for the 2 if we knew sherwin would take it?
A few kicks that went dead in goal were very very poor and even the bomb the winger dropped was a bad kick - Far too long but the winger made a howler
I do however think he defended very well - he dashed in from the wing for there first try but it was 3 on 1 so cant fault him, and made some key tackles when needed and the guy is a quality ball handler, He needs a good 6 and a decent pack to work with though
Loyalty Costs Nothing !
-
- League One Player
- Posts: 4146
- Joined: 05 Jul 2006, 18:25
- Location: Barking...
- Contact:
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 117
- Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 14:28
- Contact:
his kicking game has been poor, but i think we have been spoiled last year with D.Brough who has the best kicking game in super league IMO.
Sherwin is doing fine. Hes top of the super league try assists and without him we would be lost at the minute. Hes got a good brain on him and if he had some hard running front/second rowers like at canterbury, he would be fantastic.
Sherwin is doing fine. Hes top of the super league try assists and without him we would be lost at the minute. Hes got a good brain on him and if he had some hard running front/second rowers like at canterbury, he would be fantastic.
- corsa
- Academy Player
- Posts: 828
- Joined: 15 Mar 2007, 20:31
- Twitter: @ianhenshaw1983
- Location: Castleford
- Contact:
Re: Brent Sherwin
To be honest i aint a fan of sherwin doubt i ever will not good enough for me but thats my opinion.
- wastedyears1981
- Academy Player
- Posts: 912
- Joined: 23 Mar 2008, 18:11
- Location: Eating a baloo burger in the WRE behind the sticks.
- Contact:
-
- New member
- Posts: 5
- Joined: 15 Jul 2006, 20:25
- Contact:
Agree with previous comments, regarding Sherwin he was by far our best player, we have nobody in the team on the same wavelength as we are not thinking as quick as he is, also the team picked up when Joe came on, we need to work on our tackling technique, Mcgoldrick never goes for the legs, and Joe was laid in a crumpled heap when Luke Burgess ran into him as he went high instead of going for the legs, luckily for us Joe came back on. Hendo ought to have them in the classroom giving his advice on how to tackle correctly. Matterson needs to stop playing players out of position i.e Mcgoldrick loose forward and we need a goal kicker we are like headless chickens when we get a penalty as nobody knows what to do and who is taking the kick. Sherwin took the kick as he was near the where the offence occurred but joe and Huby were also on the pitch as well.. I'm baffled.
- dettoriman
- Super League Player
- Posts: 10692
- Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 15:25
- Twitter: Dettoriman
- Location: Probably Big Fella's
- Contact:
Huby wasnt on the field when the penalty was awarded and was only subbed on to the field as shifty was lining the kick up, You cannot sub someone on and let them take the kick like thatAiredale Tiger wrote:Agree with previous comments, regarding Sherwin he was by far our best player, we have nobody in the team on the same wavelength as we are not thinking as quick as he is, also the team picked up when Joe came on, we need to work on our tackling technique, Mcgoldrick never goes for the legs, and Joe was laid in a crumpled heap when Luke Burgess ran into him as he went high instead of going for the legs, luckily for us Joe came back on. Hendo ought to have them in the classroom giving his advice on how to tackle correctly. Matterson needs to stop playing players out of position i.e Mcgoldrick loose forward and we need a goal kicker we are like headless chickens when we get a penalty as nobody knows what to do and who is taking the kick. Sherwin took the kick as he was near the where the offence occurred but joe and Huby were also on the pitch as well.. I'm baffled.
Loyalty Costs Nothing !
-
- Academy Player
- Posts: 667
- Joined: 07 Jul 2006, 14:49
- Location: Brisbane, Australia - Where Else!
- Contact:
So you base your opinion on what you hear (or don't hear) on the radio?big-t wrote:If Matterson had any bottle he would drop McGoldrick, but he won't because of that stupid contract given to him.
But on the radio it sounded like Sherwin played as well as anyone could in a team as bad as this Cas one.
Sherwin played well, McGoldrick played out of position at loose forward, should have been in the centre to exploit their inexperience.zeuss wrote:So you base your opinion on what you hear (or don't hear) on the radio?big-t wrote:If Matterson had any bottle he would drop McGoldrick, but he won't because of that stupid contract given to him.
But on the radio it sounded like Sherwin played as well as anyone could in a team as bad as this Cas one.
Not sure what TM is thinking about moving Ryan to lock, he's a quality centre and that's where he should play, his defence in the centre is good, whereas his positional play in other areas (such as full back, where he has little experience) let's him down IMO.
Should have played Hlad in forwards and Goldy in centre, Owen on wing, left out Fletcher.
Danny Boy
- monkeyface
- Academy Player
- Posts: 1577
- Joined: 12 Oct 2007, 14:28
- Location: Pontefract
- Contact:
just as my wife said before kick off, i think you and her shopuld take the place of TM, and AH.Danny Boy wrote:Sherwin played well, McGoldrick played out of position at loose forward, should have been in the centre to exploit their inexperience.zeuss wrote:So you base your opinion on what you hear (or don't hear) on the radio?big-t wrote:If Matterson had any bottle he would drop McGoldrick, but he won't because of that stupid contract given to him.
But on the radio it sounded like Sherwin played as well as anyone could in a team as bad as this Cas one.
Not sure what TM is thinking about moving Ryan to lock, he's a quality centre and that's where he should play, his defence in the centre is good, whereas his positional play in other areas (such as full back, where he has little experience) let's him down IMO.
Should have played Hlad in forwards and Goldy in centre, Owen on wing, left out Fletcher.
Think this is what nobody gets, why cant & doesnt TM do this with players, instead of playing them out of position & where they are totally unaffective, whats wrong with the man !!Danny Boy wrote:Sherwin played well, McGoldrick played out of position at loose forward, should have been in the centre to exploit their inexperience.zeuss wrote:So you base your opinion on what you hear (or don't hear) on the radio?big-t wrote:If Matterson had any bottle he would drop McGoldrick, but he won't because of that stupid contract given to him.
But on the radio it sounded like Sherwin played as well as anyone could in a team as bad as this Cas one.
Not sure what TM is thinking about moving Ryan to lock, he's a quality centre and that's where he should play, his defence in the centre is good, whereas his positional play in other areas (such as full back, where he has little experience) let's him down IMO.
Should have played Hlad in forwards and Goldy in centre, Owen on wing, left out Fletcher.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: 5menofsteel, Ahrefs [Bot], Al letuknow1, ERG2012, gateman, Google [Bot], Mucky1978 and 87 guests