Page 1 of 2

Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 17:48
by Scoopage
Might get some stick for this but I think he’s in top 3 hookers in world rugby.he as everything.tackles,short kicking game,long kicking game,good delivery from the play the ball,links well in attack and is now scoring trys.whats other peoples thoughts

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 18:03
by old cas lass
Scoopage wrote:Might get some stick for this but I think he’s in top 3 hookers in world rugby.he as everything.tackles,short kicking game,long kicking game,good delivery from the play the ball,links well in attack and is now scoring trys.whats other peoples thoughts
Why would you get stick for that.
We can all see he’s a top notch hooker.
Got MOM today, though I thought gale controlled the game from start to finish.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 18:16
by Dixie D
Shhhhhh, don't want the NRL finding out. They all think Hodgson is the messiah don't they :) Macca is different class.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 18:33
by Scoopage
old cas lass wrote:
Scoopage wrote:Might get some stick for this but I think he’s in top 3 hookers in world rugby.he as everything.tackles,short kicking game,long kicking game,good delivery from the play the ball,links well in attack and is now scoring trys.whats other peoples thoughts
Why would you get stick for that.
We can all see he’s a top notch hooker.
Got MOM today, though I thought gale controlled the game from start to finish.
Who doesn’t get stick on here lol.but yeah gale was the difference today.hes immense.when gale doesn’t play I think mcshane should play 7.think he would dictate a game better than ellis

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 18:46
by Mr XP
I think we need an article writing on Macca...

Any takers??

;)

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 19:21
by duke street 10
McShane has been our most consistent performer this season by some distance.

I will add i thought Liam Watts was very good in the 1st half today, tackled & run hard and his passing in the link up play was impressive.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 19:36
by Kenilworth Tiger
Mr XP wrote:I think we need an article writing on Macca...

Any takers??

;)
Maybe you could give it a go, or are you just happy to do the criticising bit?

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 21:23
by Mr XP
Kenilworth Tiger wrote:
Mr XP wrote:I think we need an article writing on Macca...

Any takers??

;)
Maybe you could give it a go, or are you just happy to do the criticising bit?
Quite happy to criticise thanks :P

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 22:18
by callum_walker
Mr XP wrote:I think we need an article writing on Macca...

Any takers??

;)

I'm on it ;) on a serious note, McShane is fantastic and so important for us now.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 22:22
by Casmoley
callum_walker wrote:
Mr XP wrote:I think we need an article writing on Macca...

Any takers??

;)

I'm on it ;) on a serious note, McShane is fantastic and so important for us now.

how about a article on the fans divide...

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 15 Apr 2018, 22:30
by Mysterio
I’d like an article about an article about this thread. That’s two articles too.

On a more serious note, glad we have Macca committed.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 00:55
by Spanishtiger
Always been my favourite. Macca, that is !!!! Have said so many, many times on here, the guy's got everything.
On the bright side, he's signed for 5 years which would probably deter even the NRL clubs.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 09:05
by heritage1926
It is actually criminal that he's been overlooked for England, really is. Barring Roby, i see no English hooker anywhere near him right now. He is an absolute winner, tenacious in everything he does.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 10:22
by mart0042
The top 3 are macca, roby and parcell. Leeds and saints can't win without then and have no quality back up. We have milner. And no, dyer isn't quality back up, so much so that Golding spelled parcell against us.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 11:16
by Scoopage
mart0042 wrote:The top 3 are macca, roby and parcell. Leeds and saints can't win without then and have no quality back up. We have milner. And no, dyer isn't quality back up, so much so that Golding spelled parcell against us.
I’m talking world rugby not just super league mate

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 11:36
by mart0042
Scoopage wrote:
mart0042 wrote:The top 3 are macca, roby and parcell. Leeds and saints can't win without then and have no quality back up. We have milner. And no, dyer isn't quality back up, so much so that Golding spelled parcell against us.
I’m talking world rugby not just super league mate
I get that but he's not in Cameron Smith territory. I don't watch much nrl but isaac luke still has it.

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 16 Apr 2018, 14:34
by old cas lass
That move between him and Milner for macca’s 2nd try was top draw.
Loved the McGuire-esk dive. :D

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 17 Apr 2018, 09:50
by mart0042
old cas lass wrote:That move between him and Milner for macca’s 2nd try was top draw.
Loved the McGuire-esk dive. :D
It was so sleek, great stuff

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 20 Apr 2018, 14:37
by callum_walker

Re: Paul mcshane

Posted: 21 Apr 2018, 09:36
by NCH
Great read