Page 1 of 1

Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 22:14
by old cas lass
Kicked 4/4 tonight.
The last one right on the touch line.
I think he should be the kicker instead of Ellis.
Ellis tends to miss easyish kicks, macca should be our main kicker.

Was my MOM

Thoughts

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 22:27
by callum_walker
Could be my MOM every week, easily one of our best players!

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 22:44
by lurcher
agree he's the best kicker but how much more do we put on him? he runs himself into the ground week after week but having said that he seems to thrive on it.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 22:48
by tigerfeat
Best game I seen him have for cas

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 23:07
by Casmoley
lurcher wrote:agree he's the best kicker but how much more do we put on him? he runs himself into the ground week after week but having said that he seems to thrive on it.

exactly why DP has brought in a exceptional young talent to learn from him. Reiss Butterworth.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 13 Jul 2018, 23:57
by RonnieGibbs'forearm
He is just a class act. Ridiculously consistent.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 00:29
by the machine
old cas lass wrote:Kicked 4/4 tonight.
The last one right on the touch line.
I think he should be the kicker instead of Ellis.
Ellis tends to miss easyish kicks, macca should be our main kicker.

Was my MOM

Thoughts
Ellis kicked very well last week, was 7/7 after missing the first

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 11:49
by Scoopage
I’ve said it before and il say it again,Paul McShane one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 19:43
by cogito ergo sum
Scoopage wrote:I’ve said it before and il say it again,Paul McShane one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby
Who are the other two?

I'm assuming Roby is one.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 20:55
by chesterfieldtiger
Hodgeson?????? Pmsl

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 21:17
by Casmoley
In no particular order..

Hodgson
Roby
Clarke
Smith
Cook
Macca
Luke
Peats
Parcell
Houghton

He's definitely within the top 10.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 14 Jul 2018, 22:52
by Scoopage
I see Macca as best hooker In super league.as more strings to his bow than roby.although I appreciate what roby does for saints for many years does he carry a team in a injury crisis?does he kick an important 40/20 at a vital time of the game?can he knock a goal over from the touch line?does he have a short kicking game?does he have a long kicking game?i think Macca is better in all these aspects.nrl wise I like hodgson and as to be respected for his efforts but again feel Macca is better.i place him behind Cameron smith and yes I watch nrl aswel

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 15 Jul 2018, 11:09
by tigerfeat
Cam Smith best player Ive seen last ten years...id have macca in my top five in world at minute no doubt

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 15 Jul 2018, 22:21
by lurcher
Casmoley wrote:In no particular order..

Hodgson
Roby
Clarke
Smith
Cook
Macca
Luke
Peats
Parcell
Houghton

He's definitely within the top 10.
never rated parcell, thought leeds went much better without him against wakey..
same goes for hodgson, can't pass further than 5 metres.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 15 Jul 2018, 23:44
by 43s flyer
lurcher wrote:
Casmoley wrote:In no particular order..

Hodgson
Roby
Clarke
Smith
Cook
Macca
Luke
Peats
Parcell
Houghton

He's definitely within the top 10.
never rated parcell, thought leeds went much better without him against wakey..
same goes for hodgson, can't pass further than 5 metres.
That's if he passes at all.

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 15 Jul 2018, 23:49
by Scoopage
So what’s everyones top 3?mines
Cameron Smith
Jake friend
Paul McShane

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 16 Jul 2018, 06:56
by tigerfeat
The lad that played hooker for nsw Damien cook looks a real good player wouldn't have parcell in my top ten hodgson was dissaponting for England but as looked good for Canberra id have
Smith
Roby
Mcshane cook hodgson

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 16 Jul 2018, 07:49
by Casmoley
tigerfeat wrote:The lad that played hooker for nsw Damien cook looks a real good player wouldn't have parcell in my top ten hodgson was dissaponting for England but as looked good for Canberra id have
Smith
Roby
Mcshane cook hodgson

out of interest who's your other 5 if Parcell doesn't make it?

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 16 Jul 2018, 09:24
by tigerfeat
Casmoley wrote:
tigerfeat wrote:The lad that played hooker for nsw Damien cook looks a real good player wouldn't have parcell in my top ten hodgson was dissaponting for England but as looked good for Canberra id have
Smith
Roby
Mcshane cook hodgson

out of interest who's your other 5 if Parcell doesn't make it?
parcell was good last season dont know if hes after a move home not impressed me this season
6-10 in no particular order
mculloch
daz clark
jake friend
isaac luke
peats

Re: Paul McShane

Posted: 16 Jul 2018, 14:47
by lurcher
the trouble with parcell and hodgson is that neither seem capable of giving a long accurate pass straight from the floor. both seem to straighten up to a standing position and usually take a couple of side ways steps before giving a short pass.
maybe that's what the coach wants but for me it gives the opposition defence a vital second to get up to the attacking line.
incidentally, watch gales semi final drop goal winner. macca went on a scoot on the 4th and was tackled leaving junior at dummy half and he throws a huge pass to luke straight from the floor if I remember correctly.