Paul mcshane

[old cas lass]

Just been reading a few comments on a couple of Facebook rugby league sites.
I’ve noticed quite a few fans from other clubs are talking about macca being a candidate for MOS. What do we think. Is he consistently better than Roby, at the moment I would say yes.
He out classed daz tonight. Barba seems to have gone off the radar.

So guys and gals, what your thoughts on Paul mcshane MOS, As a nice ring to it.
Or is it ludicrous.

[tigerfeat]

Don't think barba will get it ...roby id have just ahead of macca but yeah he's got a chance

[casjunction]

Not ludicrous.
Complete player
Cheeky
Communicator
Tackler
Kicker
Get under the skin
Creative
Line speed good hands
Apart from that a pretty ordinary player
Wakefield must have been really grateful we took him off their hands and gifted them Scott Moore as a replacement.

[Swagger]

It's picked by the players not fans. I think Barba will get it. Caused players havoc this season

[gateman]

would we swap him for any other number 9 for me a big NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[RonnieGibbs'forearm]

Should def be on list. Can't see him winning it but you never know.

[Exiled]

Carney's recent SKY comments on the way that the MOS is decided was total common sense: highlighting the difference between the MOS and the Dally M. We really need to sort out the MOM and, as they do for the DM - award points for 1st 2nd 3rd MOM.

But to reply to the OP; how PM still is not in the National set up is incredible. He has to be one of the most complete rugby players in the world at the moment. It has been a tough old season for us and PM has been a leader and performing outstandingly since the off. He just seems to get better and better.

[Spanishtiger]

Without blowing any trumpets, I've been saying for months that :-

a) Macca is the best value signing that DP has ever made,

b) that he should be in the England squad,

c) that he ought to be the club captain.

Also probably the best coach in the NCL which indicates how good his rugby brain is.

[jackknife]

Carney's recent SKY comments on the way that the MOS is decided was total common sense: highlighting the difference between the MOS and the Dally M. We really need to sort out the MOM and, as they do for the DM - award points for 1st 2nd 3rd MOM.

But to reply to the OP; how PM still is not in the National set up is incredible. He has to be one of the most complete rugby players in the world at the moment. It has been a tough old season for us and PM has been a leader and performing outstandingly since the off. He just seems to get better and better.

Theres already a 1st 2nd n 3rd mom points thing going on called the Albert Goldthorpe medal

[MØL]

Carney's recent SKY comments on the way that the MOS is decided was total common sense: highlighting the difference between the MOS and the Dally M. We really need to sort out the MOM and, as they do for the DM - award points for 1st 2nd 3rd MOM.

But to reply to the OP; how PM still is not in the National set up is incredible. He has to be one of the most complete rugby players in the world at the moment. It has been a tough old season for us and PM has been a leader and performing outstandingly since the off. He just seems to get better and better.

Theres already a 1st 2nd n 3rd mom points thing going on called the Albert Goldthorpe medal

Isn't that the Luke Gale Medal. :dance: Although won't be this year.

But seriously the way sky decide the man of the match and sometimes the players they choose it'd be a right farce if we went with their picks.

[Scoopage]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

[RonnieGibbs'forearm]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Only Roby and Clark better than him in SL, although Dazzler is a different type of player in many ways.
Don't know enough about NRL to judge rest.

[jackknife]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Top 3 in SL yes in world i dont think so

[TheSheriff]

Wells said something on comms yesterday about hearing McShane might be on the shortlist for MOS.

[MØL]

I think he's the best in the world let's not forget the report at the start of the year that Australia is a made up country with everyone portraying to be Australian are actually actors.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/weird/95 ... conspiracy

[tigerfeat]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Cam Smith retiring of course
Cam Smith
Roby
Damien cook
Macca
I'd go so yeah top three or four mate

[Scoopage]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Only Roby and Clark better than him in SL, although Dazzler is a different type of player in many ways.
Don't know enough about NRL to judge rest.

Clark no way consistent enough to be classed better than mcshane.macca does it week in week out.clark doesn’t.

[Scoopage]

And AGAIN il say it.paul mcshane is one of the top 3 hookers in world rugby

Cam Smith retiring of course
Cam Smith
Roby
Damien cook
Macca
I'd go so yeah top three or four mate

Agree mate.although I have Macca and roby on a par

[takethetwo]

It’s hard to compare because Macca is a different type of hooker , he’s almost like a third half back with his rugby brain and kicking game . Daz and Roby are direct pick up and scoot players who can only play well on the back of a dominant pack . Roby still the best in the league for me though as an overall player , closely followed by Macca .

[lidds]

It’s hard to compare because Macca is a different type of hooker , he’s almost like a third half back with his rugby brain and kicking game . Daz and Roby are direct pick up and scoot players who can only play well on the back of a dominant pack . Roby still the best in the league for me though as an overall player , closely followed by Macca .

Fully agree with you there.

You wouldn't have Clarke or Roby setting up the try for junior (nice little grubber kick). Or the one for Eden's second.

A fantastic all round hooker with a brilliant rugby brain. Don't think I would swap him for any other hooker in SL