saints v hull

Super League, National Leagues and the NRL
Post Reply
User avatar
flood light tiger
Academy Player
Academy Player
Posts: 873
Joined: 25 Apr 2011, 16:36
Contact:

saints v hull

Post by flood light tiger » 12 Aug 2017, 05:40

Just watched the penalty kick from syed to win the game and 2 players from hull were in front of the kicker so why did the ref allow this kick good and the ref was in line with sneyd so he cannot say they was behind bad decision by the ref.
Image

User avatar
johnson
Academy Player
Academy Player
Posts: 508
Joined: 08 Jul 2006, 20:55
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by johnson » 12 Aug 2017, 07:49

Terrible decision to allow the kick to stand - you could clearly see they were off side.
Image

HuddsTigers
Verified
Grand Final Winner
Grand Final Winner
Posts: 15893
Joined: 31 Jan 2009, 03:55
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by HuddsTigers » 12 Aug 2017, 08:04

Had a look at the rules to clarify but not really clear. IMO although they have encroached they can only be called offside if they encroach within 10m of a defending player or if they retrieve the ball themselves, as with a kick out of hand.

I think drop outs and kick offs are different but could be wrong. Typical RFL who don't have clear rules.
In the spirit of the final Blackadder episode - Goooodbyeee!

stuey
Academy Player
Academy Player
Posts: 365
Joined: 31 May 2015, 12:02
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by stuey » 12 Aug 2017, 09:52

Bad decision, but it might keep Saints out of the top 4, so no complaints from me.

Rather Wakefield finished 4th than Saints. More chance of beating Wakefield in the semi than Saints.

User avatar
Flat Capper
Grand Final Winner
Grand Final Winner
Posts: 15173
Joined: 06 Jul 2006, 00:10
Location: Where ever I lay my fat
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by Flat Capper » 14 Aug 2017, 12:08

HuddsTigers wrote:Had a look at the rules to clarify but not really clear. IMO although they have encroached they can only be called offside if they encroach within 10m of a defending player or if they retrieve the ball themselves, as with a kick out of hand.

I think drop outs and kick offs are different but could be wrong. Typical RFL who don't have clear rules.
I believe this is correct and if you can remember the controversial GF incident a few years back when Jordan Tansey scored a try after collecting a ball that had rebounded off the posts from an attempted penalty kick. In that incident he had clearly encroached within the ten but it wasn't picked up by the officials.

On this basis and as no one encroached within ten metres of the defender, no penalty.
Image
Spreading the Cas gene pool

User avatar
old cas lass
Verified
Grand Final Winner
Grand Final Winner
Posts: 23099
Joined: 26 Dec 2007, 14:29
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by old cas lass » 14 Aug 2017, 12:29

According to Stuart Cummings the hull players were off side.
But what does he know.

I always thought players should be behind the ball when it's kicked.

TT Tiger
League One Player
League One Player
Posts: 2308
Joined: 23 Jan 2014, 15:02
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by TT Tiger » 14 Aug 2017, 12:40

Jordan Tansey wasn't for Leeds against Bradford?

User avatar
old cas lass
Verified
Grand Final Winner
Grand Final Winner
Posts: 23099
Joined: 26 Dec 2007, 14:29
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by old cas lass » 14 Aug 2017, 12:43

TT Tiger wrote:Jordan Tansey wasn't for Leeds against Bradford?
He weren't and that was a massive error by ganson.

cogito ergo sum
Academy Player
Academy Player
Posts: 1676
Joined: 20 Jun 2016, 08:47
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by cogito ergo sum » 16 Aug 2017, 18:16

In front at the kick off, penalty.

cogito ergo sum
Academy Player
Academy Player
Posts: 1676
Joined: 20 Jun 2016, 08:47
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by cogito ergo sum » 16 Aug 2017, 18:22

The law clearly states, under "Penalty Kick", the players must be behind the ball when it is kicked. So in Hull's case, the goal should be disallowed and a penalty to Saints...kickable!!!

User avatar
43s flyer
League One Player
League One Player
Posts: 2413
Joined: 04 Apr 2014, 15:46
Contact:

Re: saints v hull

Post by 43s flyer » 16 Aug 2017, 18:49

Plus the kick should have been a foot further back into Hulls half and not on the half way line.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests